Red Light Cams' Future in Flux

Brick safe from 2014 deadline, however

The past several weeks have been dotted with spurts of attention dedicated to the future of red light violation cameras in New Jersey, with lawmakers including Gov. Chris Christie opining on the devices.

The debate over the usefulness of the cameras was whisked into the spotlight by Assemblyman Declan O'Scanlon (R-Monmouth) who proposed a bill late last month that would lengthen the amber – or yellow – light by a half-second at intersections outfitted with the cameras, and prohibit a ticket from being issued at all if the violation occurred within a half-second after the traffic light turned red.

Last week, the conversation was reignited after O'Scanlon, in an interview with the Newark Star-Ledger, said a study by his office found nearly half of the towns statewide using the cameras have contracts with camera vendors that extend past Dec. 16, 2014 – the date a pilot program allowing red light cameras to operate in New Jersey ends.

Brick Township was one of the first municipalities in the state to use the red light cameras under the pilot program. According to Business Administrator Scott Pezarras, the contracts for the first two intersections outfitted with the cameras – Route 70 and Chambers Bridge Road, and Brick Boulevard and Hooper Avenue – have contracts that expire in 2014. The contract expiration date of the third intersection to get the cameras – Route 70 and Brick Boulevard – was not available.

But regardless, said Pezarras, Brick's contract with American Traffic Solutions states the vendor cannot be paid if no tickets are generated, thus protecting the town from losing money.

"If you can't give out tickets, they can't make out any money at all," he said. "Other towns have negotiated different types of terms."

American Traffic Solutions has also publicly stated municipalities would not owe any money – regardless of their contract type – if the entire program is suspended in New Jersey.

Pezarras said Brick's method of issuing tickets to "rolling" stops before otherwise-legal right turns on red does not require motorists to stop for a minimum amount of time. Police officials have told Patch in the past that simply "inching out" to check for oncoming traffic will not activate the camera sensors.

The Dec. 16, 2014 end of the pilot program is shaping up to produce a major policy debate on the part of legislators who will be tasked with weighing the issues of traffic safety and revenue generation for cash-strapped local governments with a public that could be hesitant to support the devices.

“Believe me, this wasn't my idea, so I've got no stake in this thing," Gov. Chris Christie was reported to have said on his "Ask the Governor" show on NJ 101.5 radio.

Christie said the decision to make the program permanent or end it in New Jersey was the responsibility of the legislature, according to a show transcript posted on theNewspaper.com.

If the program does become a permanent fixture in the state, there will be discussions on how Brick's participation will evolve.

"If they do adopt it as law, I assume we're going to have further discussions with the police chief and administration to see if we're going to keep them in place," said Pezarras.

Hollowman October 12, 2012 at 03:18 AM
it isnt anymore time consuming than writing any other ticket and it is in fact, as you stated, so common it would be very easy to write all day. Personally, and I only speak for myself but I'm sure my feelings are shared by others in law enforcement, the problem is this: Tailgating is a 5 point ticket. Thats HUGE. RECKLESS is only a 4 point ticket, Passing a school bus is the only other 5 pointer I can think of off the top of my head. Passing a school bus is nearly 99.9% always intentional, where as, IMHO tailgating can simply be negligent (not paying attention). I personally dont like writing someone a 5 point ticket unless they TRULY deserve it. Tailgating as they weave thru traffic, race other cars, speed, etc etc. Someone who tailgates through an intersection in order to make the light... while perhaps careless driving... I dont think warrants a 5 point tailgating ticket. Again thats just my opinion and I am allowed a certain level of discretion here. What people need to realize, and I dont think they do, is that yes most accidents are rear end "fender benders." On the standard accident report, NJ-TR1, there are boxes that ask for each driver's actions prior to the collision. If you were following to close, that box will be checked, usually with driver inattention or one other infraction. This being checked will almost certainly place you at fault with your insurance REGARDLESS if a ticket was issued. The fact of the matter is, most people just dont care.
Frederick John LaVergne for Congress October 12, 2012 at 03:43 AM
"The cameras are designed to be money generators, not prevent accidents, because of course, they can only show what happens after someone runs a light. The purpose of traffic control is to ensure motorist safety. Which the cameras do not help ensure." Best response....well done.
John Q October 12, 2012 at 05:36 AM
The company that installs and maintains these cameras (American Traffic Solutions) actually has a dummy organization called the National Coalition for Safer Roads in an attempt to insult your intelligence. Here's the link for the dopes that believe this all about safety for the public. http://thenewspaper.com/news/35/3585.asp Don,t worry, it is only a one page article unlike the 72 page adobe file Hollowman linked.
Tom Cular October 12, 2012 at 09:46 AM
John, thanks for the link. It certainly sheds some light on the issue and tends to show that it's about the money, not safety.
Debra December 24, 2012 at 06:21 AM
My son hesitated because he heard a siren,[in front of Ocean First Bank. ] There was a school bus along side him on the left. And an ambulance on the left of the bus. So as the light was changing,that slight pause to give right of way to a possible emergency vehicle,my son was already in the intersection,and he received a ticket. The yellow needs more time and a timer should be installed!!! These cameras only add confusion ,and stress,to our already over stressed lives..


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »